Copart, Inc. (CPRT) slips on EPS miss in deep earnings analysis
Copart, Inc. (CPRT) slips after a quarterly EPS miss, even as revenue edged past estimates. This deep-dive earnings analysis looks beyond the headline to margin trends, segment performance, liquidity strength, buybacks, and what softer claim volumes could mean for the stock.
Copart, Inc. (CPRT) fell about 4% after fiscal fourth-quarter EPS of $0.35 missed estimates even as revenue of $1.15B slightly beat consensus. The report suggests investors are focusing on weaker profit conversion and softer insurance claim volumes, not just the top-line beat. Long term, Copart still has a strong balance sheet, no debt, and continued share repurchases, which support the investment case.
Copart, Inc. (CPRT) slips 4% after an EPS miss. Copart reported fiscal fourth-quarter revenue of $1.15B, slightly above the $1.14B estimate, but EPS of $0.35 fell short of the $0.3832 consensus. The mixed CPRT earnings result came with heavier-than-average trading volume and a $30.58 after-hours quote.
Key Takeaways
EPS missed consensus at $0.35 versus $0.3832, while revenue beat at $1.15B versus $1.14B.
Net income reached $0.33B, down from $0.40B in the prior quarter and $0.40B in the year-ago quarter.
International operations were the strongest recent operating area, with prior-quarter revenue up 14.1% to $234.2M and operating income of $73.8M.
Copart's insurance business faces softer claim volumes, although total-loss frequency and auction selling prices remain important support points.
Management highlighted a $5.5B liquidity position, $4.2B in cash and held-to-maturity securities, no debt, and $1.6B of fiscal year-to-date share repurchases.
Analyst opinion remains positive overall, with 12 buys, 8 holds, 1 sell, and a consensus rating of Buy. JPMorgan upgraded CPRT to Overweight with a $40 target, while Barclays maintained Underweight with a $25 target.
Financial Performance: Revenue Beat, Earnings Miss
The central issue in this Copart, Inc. earnings analysis is the gap between sales and profit. Revenue of $1.15B topped the $1.14B estimate. However, EPS of $0.35 missed the $0.3832 forecast. That spread tells a less comfortable story than the revenue headline alone.
The latest quarter also marked a step down from the prior period. Revenue fell from $1.24B in the quarter ended April 30 to $1.15B in the quarter ended July 31. EPS declined from $0.43 to $0.35, while net income moved from $0.40B to $0.33B. The comparison matters because the April quarter beat its $0.4063 EPS estimate with reported EPS of $0.43.
CPRT's recent earnings history is uneven. The company reported EPS of $0.36 against a $0.3925 estimate in February 2026. It then posted $0.43 against a $0.4063 estimate in May. The latest $0.35 result therefore marks the second miss in the past three reported quarters.
Copart's business remains service-led over the longer term. For the fiscal year ended July 31, 2025, service revenue was $3,968,662,000, compared with product revenue of $678,296,000. That mix gives the company a different earnings profile from a simple vehicle reseller. Auction services, logistics, technology, and buyer access remain central to the model.
The prior quarter provides the clearest detailed view of segment economics. Global gross profit increased 3.7% to $572.6M, and gross margin reached 46.3%. U.S. gross profit was $484.1M, with a 48.3% gross margin and a 38.1% operating margin. International operating income reached $73.8M, equal to a 31.5% operating margin.
The segment contrast is important. U.S. revenue was essentially flat in the prior quarter as higher revenue per unit offset volume pressure. International revenue rose 14.1% to $234.2M. International units sold increased 5.9%, while insurance units rose 4.6% and noninsurance units increased 11.2%.
That international momentum offsets some of the pressure in the U.S. Insurance volumes remain the main concern. Global insurance units declined 2.7% in the prior quarter, while U.S. insurance units fell 4.2%. Copart direct units declined 26.3% as management shifted lower-value vehicles toward its direct-buy channel.
Market Reaction and Analyst Response
CPRT shares closed at $30.75, down 4.00%, after the earnings report. Trading volume reached 15,045,152 shares versus an average of 11,731,164. The after-hours quote stood at $30.58, showing that the initial reaction remained weak after the regular session.
The market response focused on the EPS miss rather than the modest revenue beat. That reaction makes sense for a mature compounder. Revenue can clear estimates while weaker profit conversion raises questions about near-term operating leverage, mix, and cost control.
Analyst opinion remains split, although the aggregate rating is Buy. The current consensus lists 12 buys, 8 holds, and 1 sell. JPMorgan's Jash Patwa upgraded Copart from Neutral to Overweight on September 3, 2026, and raised the price target from $32 to $40.
The cautious view is equally specific. Barclays analyst John Babcock maintained Underweight on August 26 and cut the target from $26 to $25. Stephens analyst Jeff Lick reiterated Equal-Weight with a $35 target on August 20. The published target range runs from $25 at Barclays to $62 at HSBC, reflecting a wide debate over growth durability and valuation.
A separate consensus snapshot showed an average target near $43, with five buys and one sell among six analysts. Different analyst counts reflect the timing of the updates, but the message is consistent: the long-term business earns support, while the earnings path remains contested.
Get AI research on any stock
Instant reports, daily intelligence, and an AI analyst in your pocket.
Management Commentary: Volume Pressure Versus Marketplace Strength
CEO Jeff Liaw framed the insurance slowdown as a cyclical pressure rather than a structural break. He pointed to softer claims activity as consumers adjust to higher insurance premiums. At the same time, he emphasized rising repair costs and higher auction returns as forces that increase total-loss frequency.
"We believe the long-term growth algorithm for our insurance business remains very much intact." - Jeffrey Liaw, CEO, Copart earnings call
Liaw also highlighted the marketplace's global reach. International buyers represent more than one-third of vehicles sold at U.S. Copart auctions and nearly half of auction proceeds. The buyer network spans more than 160 countries. U.S. insurance average selling prices increased 4.1% in the prior quarter and reached a seasonally adjusted record.
"The resilience of our marketplace comes from the depth and diversity of a buyer network we have spent decades cultivating, now spanning more than 160 countries worldwide." - Jeffrey Liaw, CEO, Copart earnings call
CFO Leah Stearns supplied the balance-sheet argument. Copart ended the prior quarter with approximately $5.5B of liquidity, including $4.2B in cash and held-to-maturity securities, and no debt. Free cash flow increased 12% year to date. Copart also repurchased more than 43.4 million shares for over $1.6B.
"Copart remains in an exceptionally strong financial position." - Leah Stearns, CFO, Copart earnings call
In plain English, the CFO's message was that a single weak EPS quarter does not threaten the balance sheet. The buyback also helped prior-quarter diluted EPS, though the latest miss shows that capital returns cannot replace operating growth indefinitely.
Analyst Q&A Highlights
The clearest disclosed Q&A exchange focused on fuel and transportation costs. CJS Securities analyst Bob Labick pressed management on fleet ownership, outsourcing, customer surcharges, and cost mitigation. The question went directly at a potential margin risk during a period of higher transport expenses.
"Fuel prices, transportation costs are up across the economy and talked about a lot in general." - Bob Labick, CJS Securities
Liaw confirmed that Copart uses a hybrid transportation model. The company manages an in-house truck fleet and also operates its Truck In a Box program. His response defended the operating flexibility of the model, but the exchange also put cost pass-through and fuel exposure at the center of the discussion.
"We are, as you noted, a hybrid. We do manage our own in-house truck fleet." - Jeffrey Liaw, CEO, Copart earnings call
A second pressure point came from the broader volume discussion. Liaw defended the long-term model by citing a 23.6% total-loss frequency in the first calendar quarter of 2026, almost 5 percentage points above four years earlier. The defense rests on auction economics: higher repair costs and stronger Copart returns make the total-loss route more attractive to insurers, even when claims activity softens.
That answer does not erase the near-term volume decline. It does, however, explain why management remains confident in the platform. Copart is trying to grow the value of each claim while expanding its buyer network, service tools, and noninsurance channels.
Bottom Line
CPRT earnings delivered a revenue beat but an EPS miss, and the 4% share-price decline shows that investors placed more weight on profit conversion than sales. Copart retains a strong balance sheet, global marketplace, and international growth engine, yet the next phase of the investment case depends on volume stabilization and renewed earnings growth.
Copart shares dropped because fiscal fourth-quarter EPS came in at $0.35, below the $0.3832 consensus, even though revenue slightly beat estimates at $1.15B. The market reacted more negatively to the earnings miss and weaker profit conversion than to the modest sales beat.
+Did Copart beat revenue and miss earnings in the latest quarter?
Yes. Copart reported revenue of $1.15B versus the $1.14B estimate, but EPS of $0.35 missed the $0.3832 consensus. Net income also declined to $0.33B from $0.40B in the prior quarter and the year-ago quarter.
+What are the main risks for Copart's business right now?
The biggest near-term risk is softer insurance claim volumes, especially in the U.S., where insurance units fell 4.2% in the prior quarter. Copart also noted that direct units declined 26.3% as it shifted lower-value vehicles into its direct-buy channel.
+Is Copart financially strong despite the earnings miss?
Yes. Management highlighted a $5.5B liquidity position, including $4.2B in cash and held-to-maturity securities, with no debt on the balance sheet. Copart also repurchased $1.6B of stock fiscal year to date, which supports shareholder returns.
▌The Daily Briefing · Free
A new stock idea, every evening.
One stock worth watching each weekday, plus the analysis behind it. Free, in your inbox.
▌The Full Report
Want the full picture on CPRT?
The analyst-grade research report — charts, grades, valuation, and price targets — in 10 minutes.
