Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
Built from real-time financials, refreshed daily. For a full Analyst Grade with bull/bear case, price targets, and qualitative risk analysis, generate a SIGI research report →
Range $80 – $115
Price Chart
About the company
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) is a U. S.
- CEO
- John Joseph Marchioni
- IPO
- 1980
- Employees
- 2,800
- HQ
- Branchville, NJ, US
Get TickerSpark's AI analysis on SIGI
Create an account to generate AI analysis on any ticker — technical setup, analyst consensus, earnings watch, insider pulse, financial health, and peer context. Ready in about a minute.
Get Pro Access →Already have an account? Log in
Similar companies
Peers in the same neighborhood.
- Market Cap
- $6.09B
- P/E
- 12.43
- Fwd P/E
- 11.98
- PEG
- 0.45
- P/S
- 1.13
- P/B
- 1.78
- EV/EBITDA
- 10.43
- Div Yield
- 1.71%
- Gross Margin
- 55.90%
- Op Margin
- 11.64%
- Net Margin
- 9.41%
- ROE
- 14.29%
- ROIC
- 10.35%
Latest fiscal year · YoY change
- Revenue
- $5.34B+9.8%
- Gross Profit
- $2.18B+578.6%
- Op Income
- $589.60M
- Net Income
- $466.41M+125.3%
- EPS
- $7.48+130.2%
- OCF Growth
- +12.1%
- FCF Growth
- +11.7%
- 52W High
- $105.65
- 52W Low
- $72.78
- 50D MA
- $92.54
- 200D MA
- $88.91
- Beta
- 0.28
- RSI (14)
- 68
- Avg Volume
- 493.08K
Earnings call summaries
Pick a quarter — each call distilled into takeaways, results, and a bull vs bear read.
Selective Insurance delivered a strong third quarter with double-digit operating ROE, better underwriting margins, and higher investment income, while keeping disciplined pricing and capital returns front and center.· October 23, 2026
- Operating ROE was 16.9% and EPS was $2.11 GAAP / $2.37 operating, with the combined ratio improving to 96.8.
- Net investment income rose 16% year over year to $127 million, helping support returns and offset underwriting pressure.
- Management said commercial lines mix is improving, but near-term premium growth is being sacrificed to improve underwriting quality and reduce exposure to weaker cohorts.
- Personal lines continued to improve in the target mass affluent homeowners market, while auto remained a drag on growth.
- Capital returns stepped up with a 12% dividend increase, the 13th straight annual hike, and a new $200 million share repurchase authorization.
The company reported third-quarter fully diluted EPS of $2.11 and non-GAAP operating EPS of $2.37. Operating ROE was 16.9% and GAAP ROE was 15.1%. The GAAP combined ratio was 96.8, including 5.4 points of catastrophe losses, improving 1.8 points year over year; E&S posted an 86.5 combined ratio. After-tax net investment income was $127 million, up 16% year over year, and year-to-date operating ROE was 14.3% with a GAAP combined ratio of 97.7. For full-year guidance, management continues to expect a GAAP combined ratio between 96.5% and 97.5%, now assuming 5.5 catastrophe points, down from 6.0 points previously. Full-year after-tax net investment income guidance was raised to $490 million from $480 million. The company also expects a full-year underwriting expense ratio of approximately 31.5%, implying about 32% in the fourth quarter. Management said Hurricane Isaias losses are expected to be immaterial, though it is too early for specific estimates.
John Marchioni framed the quarter as proof that Selective is prioritizing profitability over volume, pointing to stronger underwriting margins, better mix, and continued investment income strength. He emphasized that the company is building for its next growth phase through E&S retail access, broader wholesale appetite, more granular pricing, and expansion in target homeowners and selected commercial geographies. His tone was confident and disciplined, with repeated emphasis on long-term value, cycle-aware underwriting, and technology/AI as an operating lever.
Patrick Brennan highlighted the quarter’s financial strength with $2.11 of EPS, $2.37 of operating EPS, 16.9% operating ROE, and $127 million of after-tax net investment income, up 16% year over year. He said the 32.1% expense ratio was elevated partly because of lower premium volume and some premium audit-related write-offs, but full-year underwriting expense ratio guidance remains about 31.5%. On capital, he noted $3.4 billion of GAAP equity, $3.7 billion of statutory surplus, $55 million of opportunistic share repurchases in the quarter, a 12% dividend increase, and a new $200 million buyback authorization.
Analysts focused on how much of the commercial lines margin improvement came from remediation versus normal book variation, and management said the main driver was deliberate mix improvement and tougher retention on the weakest 10% of the portfolio. They also asked whether buybacks reflected the stock price or excess capital, and management said it was a combination of attractive valuation, capital flexibility, and preserving capital for future growth. Other questions centered on E&S strategy, the pace of underwriting actions, and whether commercial auto exposure declines were concentrated in certain geographies; management said E&S growth will come from more submissions, retail access, and broader appetite, while auto declines reflected lower counts and some geographic mix shifts.
The quarter showed strong profitability even as the company tightened underwriting: operating ROE was 16.9%, the combined ratio improved, and investment income grew 16%. Management also described early traction in E&S retail access, improving homeowners profitability, and a disciplined commercial strategy that should support better margins over time.
Near-term top-line growth is being deliberately restrained by higher rates, lower retention in underperforming cohorts, and slower new business conversion, especially in casualty-heavy lines. Management also said commercial auto and general liability are still not at target profitability, and the expense ratio is under some pressure from lower premium volume and ongoing investments.
AI summary of the company's earnings call · Paraphrased · Not investment advice
- Free Float
- 99.1%
- Shares Outstanding
- 59.00M
- Float Shares
- 58.49M
of shares held by institutions
378 13F filers
Buy/sell ratio 0.50. Sells can include pre-scheduled 10b5-1 plan sales, not just discretionary selling.
Congressional trading
Senate and House stock disclosures for SIGI, newest first.
| Member | Type | Traded | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lisa C. McClainHouse · MI09 | Sell | Jun 17, 25 | Filing → |
| Lisa C. McClainHouse · MI09 | Buy | Jun 11, 25 | Filing → |
| Diana HarshbargerHouse · TN01 | Buy | Feb 25, 22 | Filing → |
| Diana HarshbargerHouse · TN01 | Buy | Feb 25, 22 | Filing → |
| Diana HarshbargerHouse · TN01 | Buy | Feb 25, 22 | Filing → |
| Thomas Roland TillisSenate · NC | Sell | Feb 13, 15 | Filing → |
Source: public STOCK Act disclosures. Filed weeks after the trade — a lagging signal, not a real-time one.
Top institutional holders
Largest 13F positions, with quarter-over-quarter change.
| Holder | Shares | Δ Quarter |
|---|---|---|
| Blackrock, Inc. | 7.91M | ▲ 130.37K |
| Vanguard Group Inc | 6.63M | ▼ 85.41K |
| Vanguard Portfolio Management LLC | 3.47M | ▼ 21.60K |
| Aqr Capital Management LLC | 3.35M | ▼ 591.53K |
| Vanguard Capital Management LLC | 2.69M | ▼ 6.34K |
| American Century Companies Inc | 2.58M | ▲ 352.54K |
| State Street Corp | 2.47M | ▲ 13.87K |
| Geode Capital Management, LLC | 1.82M | ▼ 3.10K |
| Fmr LLC | 1.77M | ▼ 166.99K |
| Dimensional Fund Advisors LP | 1.59M | ▲ 143.53K |
| First Trust Advisors LP | 1.33M | ▼ 284.42K |
| Franklin Templeton Inc | 1.14M | ▲ 452.98K |
Held by 470 ETFs
Biggest fund positions in SIGI by dollar value.
Recent insider transactions
Who's buying, who's selling, and how much.
| Date | Insider | Type | Shares |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 9, 26 | Marchioni John J. | other | 12,234 |
| Nov 9, 26 | Marchioni John J. | other | 12,234 |
| Oct 26, 26 | Nicholson Cynthia S | sell | 3,691 |
| Oct 5, 26 | Kalia Vaibhav | other | 0 |
| Sep 16, 26 | Coaxum Wole C | other | 0 |
| Jul 28, 26 | Lanza Michael H | other | 1,100 |
| Jul 28, 26 | Lanza Michael H | sell | 17,100 |
| May 1, 26 | Aijala Ainar D JR | other | 1,767 |
| May 1, 26 | Parsons Julie | other | 1,767 |
| May 1, 26 | McCarthy Thomas A | other | 3,047 |
A “Sell” may be a pre-scheduled 10b5-1 plan sale rather than a discretionary decision — read insider selling with that in mind.
Our SIGI coverage
Recent articles, reports, and earnings notes.
Want a deeper read on SIGI?
Generate a full analyst-grade report — bull/bear case, price targets, valuation depth, and a complete financial breakdown.
4 Insurance Dividend Stocks With Two Ways to Make Money and Pay Shareholders
247wallst.com · Nov 11
Selective Insurance: Better Underwriting, But Not Yet Back To Its Old Standards
seekingalpha.com · Nov 10
Should Value Investors Buy Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) Stock?
zacks.com · Nov 10
SIGI Outperforms Industry, Trades at a Premium: Time to Hold or Buy?
zacks.com · Nov 2
Selective Insurance (SIGI) is a Top-Ranked Growth Stock: Should You Buy?
zacks.com · Oct 28
Selective Insurance Group (NASDAQ:SIGI) Director Cynthia Nicholson Sells 3,691 Shares of Stock
defenseworld.net · Oct 27
Selective Insurance: 3 Key Takeaways for Long-Term Investors
fool.com · Oct 25
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript
seekingalpha.com · Oct 23
Headlines from third-party outlets — TickerSpark isn't affiliated with these sources.
